Ebook Download Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee on the Offensive, by null
Well, publication Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee On The Offensive, By Null will certainly make you closer to what you want. This Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee On The Offensive, By Null will be always good pal any type of time. You could not forcedly to consistently complete over reviewing a book basically time. It will be just when you have leisure and spending couple of time to make you feel pleasure with exactly what you read. So, you could get the significance of the message from each sentence in guide.
Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee on the Offensive, by null
Ebook Download Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee on the Offensive, by null
Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee On The Offensive, By Null. In what case do you like reading a lot? What about the sort of guide Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee On The Offensive, By Null The should read? Well, everybody has their own reason why must read some publications Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee On The Offensive, By Null Mostly, it will relate to their need to get knowledge from guide Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee On The Offensive, By Null and intend to check out merely to obtain home entertainment. Books, tale e-book, and other amusing e-books come to be so popular today. Besides, the scientific publications will certainly also be the most effective need to pick, especially for the pupils, instructors, medical professionals, business person, as well as other professions that are fond of reading.
When getting this book Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee On The Offensive, By Null as referral to read, you can acquire not just motivation but also new expertise and driving lessons. It has even more than usual perks to take. What kind of publication that you review it will work for you? So, why must get this e-book entitled Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee On The Offensive, By Null in this short article? As in link download, you could get guide Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee On The Offensive, By Null by on the internet.
When getting guide Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee On The Offensive, By Null by on-line, you could read them wherever you are. Yeah, even you remain in the train, bus, waiting list, or various other locations, on-line publication Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee On The Offensive, By Null can be your good close friend. Every time is a great time to read. It will enhance your understanding, fun, amusing, driving lesson, and encounter without spending even more money. This is why online e-book Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee On The Offensive, By Null becomes most desired.
Be the first that are reviewing this Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee On The Offensive, By Null Based upon some reasons, reviewing this book will certainly provide even more perks. Even you have to read it step by action, web page by page, you could finish it whenever and anywhere you have time. As soon as a lot more, this on-line e-book Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee On The Offensive, By Null will certainly provide you easy of reading time and also activity. It also provides the encounter that is budget-friendly to get to and also get substantially for much better life.
Lee Moves North "A revisionist look at Lee's career . detailed and interesting." --Orlando Sentinel "Michael Palmer says that Robert E. Lee was 145;a man of military genius'--but only when he was reacting to a Union attack. When he analyzes Lee on the offensive, Palmer labels him a woefully inadequate general. Powerfully written, this no-holds-barred criticism of Lee the general will shake long-held perceptions of historians and buffs. Like this book or not, it is must reading." --John F. Marszalek, Mississippi State University author of Sherman: A Soldier's Passion for Order "A superb study--one that provides refreshingly new insight into the generalship of Robert E. Lee .a must for Civil War and military historians." --William N. Still Jr., coauthor of Why the South Lost "A unique and careful analysis of Lee's generalship #133;an excellent and persuasive consideration of the Marble Man." --Alan T. Nolan, author of Lee Considered Reconsidering a Confederate Legend . In a boldly revisionist look at the career, leadership capability, and decisive battles of the venerated General Robert E. Lee, prize-winning historian Michael Palmer delivers a riveting new perspective on one of the most compelling figures in United States history.
- Sales Rank: #3321439 in Books
- Published on: 1999-08-09
- Original language: English
- Number of items: 1
- Dimensions: 9.37" h x .58" w x 6.32" l, .70 pounds
- Binding: Paperback
- 189 pages
- Michael A. Palmer
- Military
- Civil War
Amazon.com Review
For much of the Civil War, Robert E. Lee and the Army of Northern Virginia fought on the defensive, but it's during three specific invasions northward--Antietam, Gettysburg, and the lesser-known Bristoe Station--that both the genius and failings of General Lee come to light. Historian Michael Palmer offers a revisionist look at how Lee, who has been at times nearly universally revered, made serious mistakes when engaging in offensive operations. Regardless of whether the reader totally agrees with Palmer's thesis, the argument is well presented, and the sources cited and Palmer's writing could engender a lively debate.
From the Publisher
Few military figures have attained the legendary status of Robert E. Lee. Yet, though he displayed tactical brilliance in the defensive mode, Lee's offensive moves were often hastily undertaken with virtually no logistical preparation. And not surprisingly, these assaults ended in defeat. Lee Moves North explores the weaknesses of Lee's leadership by focusing on three of his unsuccessful campaigns to break ground in the North: the abortive Maryland invasion in Sharpsburg of 1862, the disastrous Gettysburg campaign of 1863, and the lesser-know Bristoe Station fiasco later that year.
From the Inside Flap
Lee Moves North In a brilliant, revisionist look at the career, leadership capability, and decisive campaigns of the legendary Robert E. Lee, historian Michael A. Palmer offers a compelling new portrait of one of the most enigmatic and controversial figures of the Civil War. Venerated on both sides of the conflict, Lee nevertheless had—and continues to have—passionate detractors. Those who dispute his place in history claim that the real Robert E. Lee was a soldier whose faults were so marked that he not only failed to defend the Confederacy, but also was himself a cause of its undoing. The truth, Palmer shows, is more complex, for while Lee displayed undisputed tactical brilliance when fighting on the defensive, his strategic offensives often led to disaster. Lee Moves North explains, in riveting detail, why a commander who won a spectacular success at Chancellorsville in May 1863 could suffer so terrible a defeat only two months later at Gettysburg. In a fascinating analysis of Lee’s generalship, Palmer forcefully argues that the celebrated leader had a penchant for hastily planned offensives undertaken with virtually no logistical preparation. Drawing on extensive documentation, including Lee’s personal correspondence, Michael Palmer focuses on the crucial period between September 1862 and November 1863—specifically, three decisive campaigns: the abortive Maryland invasion that ended at Sharpsburg, the landmark battle of Gettysburg, and the lesser-known Bristoe Station fiasco that came shortly thereafter. As he vividly recreates the battles and maneuvers, Palmer offers new interpretations of several hotly debated episodes, including J. E. B. "Jeb" Stuart’s infamous ride around the Federal army during the Gettysburg campaign. Was the alternate plan outlined by Lee in fact unworkable? Lee Moves North reveals how the general’s penchant for secrecy about his plans—a prerequisite for the political battle he waged with his superiors in Richmond—undermined the Army of Northern Virgina. Keeping his true intentions hidden from President Jefferson Davis and Secretary of War James Seddon meant also keeping the plans secret from even the army’s trusted corps commanders. As a result, inadequate support, poor or nonexistent staff work, and confusion about campaign objectives all contributed to failure. In fact, Palmer’s meticulously crafted account demonstrates a direct correlation between the troubled relationship of Lee and Davis and the actual outcome on the battlefield. Powerful and persuasive, Lee Moves North is a bold and beautifully detailed work, and a requisite addition to any Civil War collection.
Most helpful customer reviews
17 of 19 people found the following review helpful.
An excellent study of Robert E. Lee's strategic failures
By A Customer
Michael Palmer's analysis of Confederate General Robert E. Lee's strategic operations during the American Civil War reveals a general who was (and remains) without peer as a tactical genius, but also one who possessed dubious talents as a military strategist. Palmer focuses on three notable strategic offensives undertaken by the Confederate Army of Northern Virginia under Lee's command: The Sharpsburg campaign of September 1862, the Gettysburg campaign of June-July 1863 and the Bristoe Station campaign of late 1863. All three campaigns possessed several common characteristics: (1) A lack of proper logistical support for the forces in the field (2) The lack of a clear-cut military objective. As a consequence, all three Confederate strategic campaigns ended in a stalemate and the withdrawal of the Army of Northen Virginia from the fields of battle. In defense of Lee, it has been speculated that Lee's strategic judgement was impaired as the Gettysburg campaign began in June 1863 due to a heart ailment and that he suffered a heart attack at the height of the battle in early July 1863. In the end, these failed strategic offensives contributed - along with the Union's superior manpower reserves, overwhelming industrial production facilities and the hard-won quality of its officers and enlisted men - to the defeat of the Confederacy. Palmer's work is an excellent study of Robert E. Lee's strategic mind and is worthy of study, reflection and debate by students and scholars of the American Civil War.
16 of 19 people found the following review helpful.
Lee's Offensive Strategy
By E. E Pofahl
In the book's preface, Professor Palmer asks the thought provoking question "Did he and his lieutenants simply have a couple of bad days? Or were there other factors at work? ....could the strategic offensive, then be the shared thread, the common denominator that might help to explain Lee's failures?" He then reviews Lee's Maryland, Gettysburg and Bristoe Station campaigns to answer his question.
In Chapter 1, Palmer states that lacking published plans and with an ambiguous objective, Lee moved into Maryland without Jeff Davis's prior approval . The author asserts that the Maryland campaign was a Federal success and allowed "the Lincoln administration to solidify its political support...." Quite the contrary happened. Aghast at the Antietam casualties, northern voters in the 1862 fall elections for governors and congressmen, gave Lincoln's party several major reverses. The chapter makes the ridiculous comparison that "Lee was one of many southerners caught up in a wave of `victory disease', not unlike that which gripped the Japanese before the battle of Midway". The Japanese defeat at Midway was not due to "victory disease" but due to their naval code having been broken and Admiral Nagumo's bad tactical decision,
Nevertheless, regarding Maryland, Professor Palmer correctly writes "Why had Lee failed? The answer is simple: virtually all of the assumptions upon which he based his plans were unfounded."
The Gettysburg campaign chapter is well written and objective. The review of events leading to the Gettysburg campaign is excellent. Normally given limited coverage, the narration of the meetings in Richmond with Davis and his cabinet plus the correspondence regarding Lee's Gettysburg campaign is very interesting. Palmer reviews Lee's organization problems writing "....two of the three men leading corps and three of the nine men leading divisions were untested at their new levels of commands....Such dramatic changes in the organization and leadership....suggested the need for delays, not haste." Considerable space is devoted to whether Lee wanted to fight a major battle in Pennsylvania quoting Lee stating in 1868 that "he did not want to fight" and ending with Lee biographer Emory Thomas's statement "that battle was central to Lee's plan."
Palmer noted "....two fundamental forces worked against the successful execution of Lee's campaign, First....it was never was properly developed....Second, Lee relied on a very decentralized approach to command and control." Lee's decentralized command philosophy required component subordinates. Regarding the competence at Gettysburg of Lee's key commanders, Stuart, Ewell, and Longstreet , the book provides a brief review of their failures concluding that "....while Ewell's incompetence and Longstreet's recalcitrance were important factors, Lee's unwillingness to issue direct orders or to take charge of the battle lay at the root of the problem".
Analysis of Lee's strategic offensive continues with a review of the Bristoe Station campaign. Again Lee initiated a campaign in secrecy, without a clearly stated objective, no detailed operation plan and limited or misleading communications to Richmond. The author speculates that one motive for the campaign was to prevent further detachment of Lee's troops to the west and states "Lee moved north to engage Meade because the latter had not come south....Had Meade been more aggressive in August or Lee been able to take the offensive, Davis would never have sent Longstreet west." The book notes that the command problems evident at Gettysburg had not been corrected and lacking capable corps commanders another debacle occurred. Professor Palmer states that "while Heth and Hill were blamed, Lee also bore some responsibility for the failures of his subordinates" and concludes at Bristoe Station "....for Lee to attack an army twice the size of his own in October was absurd."
Evaluating Lee, in the fourth and final chapter the author asks the critical question "Could the South have won the Civil War?" Professor Palmer contends that while the North had countless advantages, the Confederacy had several advantages noting that the South did not need to invade or conquer the North to win stating "The Confederacy had only to survive until the Yankees lost their will to continue the struggle." Referencing the writings of Clausewitz and Delbruck, Southern strategies are evaluated noting that the Confederate government failed to adopt either a strategy of exhaustion or of annihilation. He further states that Lee's contributed to the South's failure to adopt a consistent strategic policy in that he usurped Davis's role as commander-in chief while Davis failed to respond and shape a well-defined national strategy.
Professor Palmer writes Lee launched all three offensives without anything approaching a formal plan basically commanding by the seat of his pants. He writes "LEE'S TWIN PENCHANTS for the offensive and for secrecy contorted the outline of Confederate national strategy between 1862 and 1863 and led to his own failures as a commander." He notes that the traits that served Lee so well for strategic defense failed him when his army went over to the strategic offensive.
The book's weakness is that it does not ask "why ?" With Lee's respect for authority, why didn't Davis control strategy directing Lee to comply and fully reveal his plans? Why would a commander noted for honesty and integrity try to deceive Richmond? Regarding a strictly defensive strategy, was Lee independently responding to Frederick the Great's chilling aphorism "He who defends everything, defends nothing."? Why was Lee secretive, was it solely to deceive or was it basically because both North and South were getting critical intelligence from the newspapers? Etc.
Some may take offense at the concluding statement "...what Lee failed to understand was that a commander of an army can no more effectively shape national strategy on the sly and on the cheap, than a tail can wag a dog." But for the historian or serious student of the Civil War, this short book is worth reading as thought provoking, often controversial, issues are raised.
0 of 0 people found the following review helpful.
Four Stars
By stephen j staback
a clear look at the offensive mind of robert e lee
Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee on the Offensive, by null PDF
Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee on the Offensive, by null EPub
Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee on the Offensive, by null Doc
Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee on the Offensive, by null iBooks
Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee on the Offensive, by null rtf
Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee on the Offensive, by null Mobipocket
Lee Moves North: Robert E. Lee on the Offensive, by null Kindle
Tidak ada komentar:
Posting Komentar